A finance director asks a simple question: "Why are we still paying line rental on phones half the team never uses?" It is a fair challenge. Traditional landlines are being withdrawn, prices have crept up, and the way people actually make calls has changed. This guide compares business landlines and Voice over Internet Protocol (VoIP) head to head — on cost, features, reliability and mobility — and explains what the retirement of the old phone network means for you. It also covers when a landline still earns its place, and how to move to a digital service while keeping your existing numbers.
Are traditional landlines being switched off?
Yes, in effect. The Public Switched Telephone Network (PSTN) — the copper-based system that has carried voice calls for decades — is being retired. Openreach stopped selling new analogue and ISDN (Integrated Services Digital Network) lines in most areas, and the full switch-off is scheduled for the end of January 2027. After that, voice services run over an internet connection rather than a dedicated copper pair.
This is often called the digital landline switch, or PSTN replacement. It affects more than desk phones. Anything that quietly relies on an analogue line can be caught out: alarm panels, lift emergency phones, door entry systems, fax machines, payment terminals and some CCTV links. Part of planning a move is simply finding what is still plugged into the old network.
The takeaway is straightforward. This is not a choice you can defer indefinitely. It is a migration with a deadline, and it is better to move on your own timetable than to be forced onto a replacement at short notice when your line stops working.
What VoIP actually is (and why it replaces the landline)
VoIP converts your voice into data and sends it over your internet connection. Instead of a physical line per phone, you have user accounts and handsets — physical desk phones, a computer app, or a mobile app — that register to a hosted platform. Two common forms are a cloud hosted PBX (Private Branch Exchange) and a Microsoft Teams phone system.
The practical difference is that your phone system stops being a box on the wall and becomes a service. Adding a user is a configuration change, not an engineer visit. Numbers, call routing and voicemail live in the cloud, so they follow the user rather than the desk.
Underlying connectivity matters more than it used to. If voice and data share the same broadband, call quality depends on that line being stable. For a small office a good business broadband service is usually fine; for a busy contact team or a multi-site business, a leased line or SD-WAN gives the consistent bandwidth and prioritisation that voice needs.
Business landline vs VoIP: cost breakdown
The clearest saving is in line rental and call charges. A traditional setup bills you for each line plus per-minute or bundled call costs. VoIP typically charges a per-user monthly fee that includes UK landline and mobile calls, so costs scale with people rather than physical lines.
Upfront costs differ too. Legacy systems often involve on-premises hardware, maintenance contracts and engineer callouts for moves and changes. VoIP shifts most of that into the subscription, though you may still buy handsets. Treat the figures below as indicative ranges — your actual costs depend on user numbers, call profile and contract length.
The honest caveat: VoIP is not free of infrastructure cost. If your internet is unreliable, the right comparison includes upgrading connectivity or adding backup connectivity. Factor that in rather than comparing the phone bill alone.
- Traditional landline: line rental per line, call charges on top, separate maintenance and engineer callout fees, hardware refresh every several years.
- VoIP: per-user monthly fee usually including UK call bundles, minimal on-site hardware, changes handled remotely at no callout cost.
- Hidden VoIP costs to include: sufficient business internet, handsets, and possibly a backup connection for resilience.
- Hidden landline costs to include: rising line rental, ISDN premiums, and the eventual forced migration before the switch-off.
Feature comparison: reliability, mobility and call handling
On features, the gap is wide. Traditional landlines do voice well and little else. VoIP brings call handling that used to require expensive equipment: auto-attendants, hunt groups, call queues, voicemail-to-email, call recording and reporting, all managed from a browser.
Mobility is the biggest practical win. With a softphone app, staff take their extension and business number anywhere — home, a client site, or abroad — using the same caller ID. For hybrid teams this removes the split between the desk number and the mobile. A Teams phone system goes further by putting calls inside the same app people already use for meetings and chat.
Reliability is where landlines held a genuine edge, and it deserves honesty. A copper line often kept working in a power cut because it drew power down the line. VoIP depends on your electricity and internet. The counter is that VoIP fails over gracefully: if an office loses connectivity, calls can divert automatically to mobiles or another site. You engineer resilience rather than relying on one line.
When does a landline still make sense?
A digital replacement is right for most businesses, but a few situations still call for care. Where a single analogue line supports a life-safety system — a lift phone or an alarm that dials out — you need a properly certified replacement path, not simply a VoIP adapter, and this should be planned with the equipment vendor.
Sites with poor or no reliable internet are the other case. VoIP quality depends on connectivity, so if a rural site has weak broadband and no leased line option, an interim analogue-style service or a fixed wireless connection may bridge the gap. Even then, this is a temporary position given the switch-off.
So it is less "landline versus VoIP" and more "what do we replace each line with?" A desk phone becomes a VoIP user. An alarm line becomes a certified alarm-grade connection. A card machine may move to a mobile data path. Mapping each use to the right replacement is the real work, and it is where network consultancy earns its keep.
How to switch and keep your existing numbers
The number one concern is usually keeping the phone numbers customers already know. You can. Numbers are ported from your current provider to the new VoIP platform. Porting takes planning and a short coordination window, but geographic numbers — including London 020 numbers — move across, and you keep them.
A sensible migration runs in a few stages. First, audit every line and what depends on it. Second, confirm connectivity is fit for voice, adding a backup path where uptime matters. Third, provision users, build the call flows and test them. Finally, port the numbers on an agreed date and decommission the old lines once everything is confirmed live.
Do not underestimate the audit. The failures we see are rarely the desk phones — they are the forgotten door intercom or the fax line in the warehouse. Planning the move alongside your wider connectivity and telecoms and Microsoft 365 support keeps voice, network and collaboration tools working together rather than as separate projects.
Making the decision for your business
For a small office, VoIP on solid business broadband with a modest set of user licences is usually the simplest, cheapest outcome. You lose the copper line and gain flexibility, and the per-user cost is predictable.
For a multi-site business or a team that handles high call volumes, the decision extends to connectivity and resilience. Here you want prioritised voice traffic, a backup connection, and centralised call routing across sites — the case for a leased line and structured call handling is strong.
Whichever way you lean, the deadline removes "do nothing" as a long-term option. The practical choice is when and how you migrate, and how much resilience you build in. If you want a second opinion on your current lines and a costed comparison, our team can review your setup — get in touch.
